Editor 1 Interpretation

Old Pictures In Florence: A Masterpiece of Poetry

Have you ever been to Florence? If you have, you must have been struck by the beauty of its art, architecture, and history. And if you haven't, you can still experience the magic of Florence through Robert Browning's poem "Old Pictures In Florence." This masterpiece of poetry captures the essence of Florence's art and culture, and invites us to reflect on the nature of art, memory, and time.

Let us delve into the rich tapestry of Browning's poem and explore its themes, images, and language.

Background

First, a little background on Robert Browning. He was an English poet who lived from 1812 to 1889, and is considered one of the foremost Victorian poets. He wrote many poems that are now considered classics, such as "My Last Duchess," "The Pied Piper of Hamelin," and "Porphyria's Lover." Browning was also a great admirer of Italian art and culture, and spent many years living in Italy, particularly in Florence.

"Old Pictures In Florence" was first published in 1855, as part of a collection of poems titled "Men and Women." The poem consists of two parts: "The Bishop Orders His Tomb At Saint Praxed's Church" and "Fra Lippo Lippi."

In the first part, the speaker is a bishop who is ordering his tomb to be made in a church. He describes the different elements of the tomb, such as the marble, the gold, and the jewels. He also reflects on his life and his sins, and how he hopes his tomb will be a symbol of his repentance and redemption.

In the second part, the speaker is Fra Lippo Lippi, a Renaissance painter who is being interrogated by the authorities for wandering the streets at night. Fra Lippo defends himself by saying that he needs to observe real life in order to paint it, and that his art is a way of communicating truth and beauty to the people. He also talks about his struggles as an artist, and how he has to navigate the demands of his patrons and the Church.

Themes

One of the main themes of "Old Pictures In Florence" is the relationship between art and reality. Both the bishop and Fra Lippo are engaged in creating art, but they approach it in very different ways. The bishop wants his tomb to be a representation of his ideal self, his perfect image. He sees art as a way of transcending reality, of creating something that is eternal and unchanging. Fra Lippo, on the other hand, wants his art to reflect the messy, chaotic, and unpredictable reality of life. He sees art as a way of engaging with reality, of bringing it to life in a new and meaningful way.

Another theme that runs through the poem is the idea of memory and time. The bishop is obsessed with his legacy, with how he will be remembered after he dies. He sees his tomb as a way of preserving his memory, of ensuring that his name will live on. Fra Lippo, on the other hand, is more interested in the present moment. He sees his art as a way of capturing the fleeting beauty of life, of making something that will be enjoyed by people in the here and now.

Finally, the poem explores the tensions between art and society. Both the bishop and Fra Lippo are part of a larger social structure, one that values art for different reasons. The bishop sees art as a way of glorifying God and the Church, while Fra Lippo sees it as a way of expressing his own individuality and creativity. The poem asks us to consider how art can be both a product of society and an instrument of change, and how artists can navigate the demands of their patrons and their own artistic vision.

Images

One of the most striking aspects of "Old Pictures In Florence" is its use of vivid and evocative imagery. Browning uses language to bring the art and architecture of Florence to life, to make us feel as if we are there in the city, surrounded by its beauty and history.

For example, in the first part of the poem, the bishop describes his tomb in rich detail, using metaphors and similes to help us imagine it:

Here's the intricate inlaid-work,
Here's the gold, do you see, to amuse the Beholder's eye,
You and your friend? O I told you so!
Eh? the whole should content you, what's outside?``

The bishop's tomb is not just a physical object, but a work of art that is meant to dazzle and impress. The use of the word "inlaid-work" suggests the precision and detail of the craftsmanship, while the phrase "to amuse the Beholder's eye" suggests that the tomb is meant to be a spectacle, something that is meant to entertain and impress.

Similarly, in the second part of the poem, Fra Lippo describes the streets of Florence at night, using language that is both sensual and atmospheric:

As if your cherished stare bade me, my heart
Bursting its enclosure: for, a single hour,
While the sun laughed, a minute made me mirth—
The sudden heaven-sent understanding!```

Fra Lippo's description of the night suggests a world that is full of life and energy, a world that is full of possibility and inspiration. The use of the phrase "sudden heaven-sent understanding" suggests that art is not just a product of the artist's skill, but also of something that is beyond their control, something that comes from a higher power.

## Language

Finally, let us consider the language of "Old Pictures In Florence." Browning's use of language is both poetic and conversational, using a mix of formal and informal language to create a sense of intimacy and immediacy.

For example, in the first part of the poem, the bishop switches from using formal language to using a more colloquial style, as if he is addressing the reader directly:

```"You can't conceive
How doings fade out of the odd years' reach,
How, when I was a boy, the thought of the day
Outdid the thought of any eve-of-day```

This sudden shift in tone creates a sense of intimacy and immediacy, as if the bishop is confiding in us, sharing his secrets and his regrets.

Similarly, in the second part of the poem, Fra Lippo uses language that is both poetic and conversational, a mix of formal and informal language that creates a sense of spontaneity and energy:

```"Ay, do you see, that angel?```

Fra Lippo's use of the phrase "Ay, do you see" suggests a casual, conversational tone, as if he is speaking to us as if we were his friends.

## Conclusion

"Old Pictures In Florence" is a masterpiece of poetry, a work that captures the beauty and complexity of Florence's art and culture. Through its themes, images, and language, the poem invites us to reflect on the nature of art, memory, and time, and to consider the tensions between art and society. Browning's use of language is both poetic and conversational, a mix of formal and informal language that creates a sense of intimacy and immediacy. I highly recommend this poem to anyone who loves art, poetry, and the beauty of language.

Editor 2 Analysis and Explanation

Old Pictures In Florence: A Masterpiece of Robert Browning

Robert Browning, one of the most celebrated poets of the Victorian era, is known for his dramatic monologues that explore the complexities of human nature. Among his many works, "Old Pictures In Florence" stands out as a masterpiece that captures the essence of art and its power to evoke emotions and memories.

The poem is set in Florence, Italy, a city renowned for its rich cultural heritage and artistic treasures. Browning takes us on a journey through the city's art galleries, where he encounters a series of old paintings that trigger a flood of memories and emotions. The poem is a reflection on the power of art to transcend time and space and connect us with the past.

The poem begins with the speaker standing in front of an old painting of a woman. The painting is faded and worn, but it still retains its beauty and power. The speaker is struck by the woman's gaze, which seems to follow him wherever he goes. He is reminded of a time long ago when he was in love with a woman who had the same piercing gaze. The painting becomes a portal through which the speaker can revisit his past and relive his memories.

Browning's use of imagery is particularly striking in this poem. He describes the painting in vivid detail, using words like "faded," "dim," and "worn" to convey its age and fragility. At the same time, he also highlights the painting's beauty and power, describing the woman's gaze as "alive and intense." The contrast between the painting's age and the woman's timeless beauty creates a sense of nostalgia and longing that permeates the entire poem.

As the speaker moves through the art gallery, he encounters other paintings that evoke different emotions and memories. He sees a painting of a man with a sword, which reminds him of his own youth and the dreams he once had of being a hero. He sees a painting of a group of people gathered around a table, which reminds him of the joys of friendship and companionship. Each painting becomes a window into a different aspect of the speaker's past, and each evokes a different set of emotions.

One of the most powerful moments in the poem comes when the speaker encounters a painting of a woman who is holding a child. The painting is so lifelike that the speaker feels as though he could reach out and touch the child's hand. He is reminded of his own childhood and the love and warmth he felt from his mother. The painting becomes a symbol of the universal bond between mother and child, and the speaker is moved to tears by its beauty and power.

Browning's use of language in this section of the poem is particularly effective. He describes the painting in such detail that the reader can almost see it in their mind's eye. He uses words like "warmth," "tenderness," and "love" to convey the emotions that the painting evokes. The result is a powerful and moving tribute to the power of art to connect us with our deepest emotions and memories.

As the poem draws to a close, the speaker reflects on the transience of life and the power of art to transcend it. He realizes that the paintings he has seen will outlast him and that they will continue to evoke emotions and memories long after he is gone. He also realizes that the paintings are not just objects of beauty, but also windows into the human soul. They reveal the joys and sorrows, the hopes and fears, of those who came before us, and they remind us of our own humanity.

In conclusion, "Old Pictures In Florence" is a masterpiece of Victorian poetry that explores the power of art to evoke emotions and memories. Browning's use of imagery, language, and symbolism is masterful, and the poem is a testament to the enduring power of art to connect us with our past and our humanity. Whether we are standing in front of an old painting in Florence or reading a poem in our own home, we can all be moved by the beauty and power of art.

Editor Recommended Sites

Recommended Similar Analysis