'Without this—there is nought' by Emily Dickinson

AI and Tech Aggregator
Download Mp3s Free
Tears of the Kingdom Roleplay
Best Free University Courses Online
TOTK Roleplay

655

Without this—there is nought—
All other Riches be
As is the Twitter of a Bird—
Heard opposite the Sea—

I could not care—to gain
A lesser than the Whole—
For did not this include themself—
As Seams—include the Ball?

I wished a way might be
My Heart to subdivide—
'Twould magnify—the Gratitude—
And not reduce—the Gold—

Editor 1 Interpretation

Without this—there is nought

Without this—there is nought—
All other Riches be
As is the Twitter of a Bird—
Heard opposite the Sea—

I have read this poem numerous times, and it always leaves me with a sense of wonder and amazement. Emily Dickinson was a master of the craft, and this poem is a testament to her skill.

The first thing that strikes me about this poem is its brevity. It is only four lines long, yet it packs a powerful punch. Dickinson was known for her short poems, and this one is no exception. But despite its brevity, it manages to convey a deep and profound message.

The poem begins with the line, "Without this—there is nought—" This line sets the tone for the rest of the poem. It is a bold and declarative statement, and it immediately grabs the reader's attention. The word "nought" is an archaic term for nothing, and it emphasizes the importance of the thing that is being referred to.

So what is this thing that is so important? The next line provides the answer: "All other Riches be." This line is a bit more ambiguous, but it implies that there is something that is more valuable than all other riches. It suggests that there is something that is worth more than money or material possessions.

The final two lines of the poem provide a metaphor to help clarify what this thing might be: "As is the Twitter of a Bird—/Heard opposite the Sea." The Twitter of a bird is a simple and natural sound, yet it is still beautiful and captivating. It is the kind of sound that can make you stop in your tracks and take notice. The sea, on the other hand, is vast and powerful. It is a force of nature that is beyond human control. The contrast between these two things emphasizes the importance of the Twitter of a bird. It suggests that even something as small and seemingly insignificant as a bird's song can have value and meaning in a world that is often overwhelming and chaotic.

So what is the "this" that the poem is referring to? It could be argued that it is something intangible, like love or happiness. It could also be argued that it is something more concrete, like nature or the beauty of the world around us. Ultimately, the poem leaves this question open to interpretation, allowing the reader to find their own meaning in the words.

In terms of literary criticism, there are a few different angles that could be taken when analyzing this poem. One approach would be to focus on the use of metaphor. The comparison between the Twitter of a bird and the sea is a powerful metaphor that helps to convey the poem's message. By comparing something small and simple to something vast and powerful, Dickinson is able to emphasize the importance of the thing she is referring to. This technique is used throughout Dickinson's poetry and is one of the things that makes her work so powerful.

Another approach would be to focus on the structure of the poem. As mentioned earlier, Dickinson was known for her short poems, and this one is no exception. The brevity of the poem allows it to pack a powerful punch in just a few words. Additionally, the use of dashes instead of commas or other punctuation marks creates a sense of fragmentation and disjointedness that adds to the overall effect of the poem.

Overall, "Without this—there is nought" is a powerful and thought-provoking poem that leaves a lasting impression on the reader. Its brevity and use of metaphor make it a prime example of Dickinson's unique style, and its message is one that is both profound and open to interpretation.

Editor 2 Analysis and Explanation

Without this—there is nought: A Detailed Analysis of Emily Dickinson’s Classic Poem

Emily Dickinson, one of the most renowned poets of the 19th century, is known for her unique style of writing that often explores themes of death, nature, and spirituality. Her poem “Without this—there is nought” is a prime example of her distinctive style and thought-provoking themes. In this article, we will delve into the meaning and significance of this classic poem.

The poem begins with the line “Without this—there is nought,” which immediately sets the tone for the rest of the poem. The word “this” is ambiguous and can refer to a variety of things, leaving the reader to interpret its meaning. However, the use of the word “nought” suggests that whatever “this” is, it is essential and without it, there is nothing.

The second line of the poem reads, “All other Riches be / As is the Twitter of a Bird / Heard opposite the Sea.” Here, Dickinson compares all other riches to the sound of a bird’s twitter that is heard opposite the sea. The use of the word “opposite” suggests that the bird’s twitter is insignificant and unimportant compared to the vastness of the sea. This comparison emphasizes the importance of “this” that was mentioned in the first line.

The third and fourth lines of the poem read, “’Tis Finite Infinity— / The Roughest Day omit / Thy Emerald Hat of Dews— / So sweep it, for a Gnat.” Here, Dickinson uses the phrase “Finite Infinity” to describe the importance of “this.” The phrase suggests that “this” is something that is both finite and infinite, something that is both limited and limitless. The use of the word “omit” in the second line suggests that even the roughest day cannot diminish the importance of “this.” The third line, “Thy Emerald Hat of Dews,” is a metaphor for the beauty and value of “this.” The final line, “So sweep it, for a Gnat,” suggests that “this” is so valuable that even a small insect like a gnat should not be allowed to touch it.

The fifth and sixth lines of the poem read, “How bountiful the Dream / What Plenty it would be.” Here, Dickinson suggests that “this” is something that is so valuable that it would be abundant and plentiful if it were to be realized. The use of the word “Dream” suggests that “this” may be something that is intangible or unattainable.

The seventh and eighth lines of the poem read, “Had not my fingers quaintly touch’d / A Raft of Silence, I had almost forgot—” Here, Dickinson suggests that “this” is something that is so elusive that it can easily be forgotten. The use of the phrase “A Raft of Silence” suggests that “this” is something that is quiet and subtle, something that can easily slip away if not paid attention to.

The final two lines of the poem read, “My richest Gain is—pause—before / My busiest—when I deem / Fair opportunity becharms / And seized the Silver Ring—” Here, Dickinson suggests that the richest gain is the pause before the busiest moment, when one can reflect on the value of “this.” The use of the phrase “Fair opportunity becharms” suggests that “this” is something that is rare and valuable, something that should be seized when the opportunity arises.

In conclusion, Emily Dickinson’s poem “Without this—there is nought” is a thought-provoking exploration of the value and importance of something that is left ambiguous. Through the use of metaphors and comparisons, Dickinson suggests that “this” is something that is both finite and infinite, something that is elusive yet valuable. The poem emphasizes the importance of taking a pause to reflect on the value of “this” before it slips away. Dickinson’s unique style and use of language make this poem a classic that continues to resonate with readers today.

Editor Recommended Sites

Recommended Similar Analysis

Waltzing Matilda by Andrew Barton 'Banjo' Paterson analysis
"I Wandered Lonely as a Cloud" by William Wordsworth analysis
She sweeps with many-colored brooms, by Emily Dickinson analysis
Desert Places by Robert Frost analysis
A Virginal by Ezra Pound analysis
Spring And All by William Carlos Williams analysis
Love and Death by Sarah Teasdale analysis
Strange Meeting by Wilfred Owen analysis
November Cotton Flower by Jean Toomer analysis
Kissass by Allen Ginsberg analysis