Editor 1 Interpretation

The Plot Against The Giant by Wallace Stevens: A Comprehensive Literary Criticism and Interpretation

Wow, where do I even begin with this masterpiece of a poem? The Plot Against The Giant by Wallace Stevens is an intricately woven tapestry of language, imagery, and symbolism that explores the complex relationship between reality and imagination, truth and fiction, and the human desire for power and control. In this 4000-word literary criticism and interpretation, I will delve into the themes, structure, language, and symbolism of The Plot Against The Giant in an attempt to uncover the hidden layers of meaning that make this poem a timeless classic. Get ready for a wild ride!

Themes

At its core, The Plot Against The Giant is a poem about the power of the human imagination to shape and transform reality. The giant in the poem represents the forces of nature, the unknown, and the uncontrollable aspects of life that humans seek to conquer and subdue. The plot against the giant, then, represents the human desire for power and control over the natural world. This theme is evident throughout the poem, from the opening lines:

First Girl

When this yokel comes maundering,

Whetting his hacker,

I shall run before him,

Diffusing the civilest odors

Out of geraniums and unsmelled flowers.

Here, the girl's plan to diffuse the odors of flowers is a metaphor for the human desire to conquer and control nature through cultivation and domestication. The poem also explores the tension between reality and imagination, truth and fiction, as the plot against the giant unfolds. The characters in the poem create a fictional narrative in which they are the heroes and the giant is the villain. This narrative serves as a way for them to gain power and control over the natural world, but it ultimately proves to be a false and unsustainable reality.

Structure

The Plot Against The Giant is divided into six sections, each of which focuses on a different character or group of characters involved in the plot against the giant. The sections are titled First Girl, Second Girl, Third Girl, Fourth Girl, Fifth Girl, and Sixth Girl, and they follow a loose narrative structure. Each section begins with a description of the character's plan to defeat the giant, followed by a description of the character's imagined victory over the giant. The sections are connected by a recurring refrain, "They said, You have a blue guitar, You do not play things as they are." This refrain serves as a reminder of the tension between reality and imagination that runs throughout the poem.

Language

One of the most striking features of The Plot Against The Giant is its use of language. Stevens's language is rich and evocative, filled with vivid imagery and unexpected turns of phrase. Take, for example, the opening lines of the poem:

When this yokel comes maundering,

Whetting his hacker,

I shall run before him,

Diffusing the civilest odors

Out of geraniums and unsmelled flowers.

Here, Stevens uses language to create a vivid sensory experience for the reader. We can imagine the smell of the flowers, the sound of the hacker being whetted, and the movement of the characters as they run from the giant. Throughout the poem, Stevens's language is filled with unexpected juxtapositions and surprising images, such as "The green freedom of a cockatoo / That mocks the cult of the zoo."

Symbolism

The Plot Against The Giant is a poem rich in symbolism. The giant, as I mentioned earlier, represents the forces of nature and the uncontrollable aspects of life that humans seek to conquer and subdue. The girls who plot against the giant represent the human desire for power and control over the natural world. The blue guitar, which is mentioned repeatedly throughout the poem, represents the transformative power of the imagination. The guitar is blue, which is a color often associated with sadness and melancholy, but it is also an instrument that can be used to create beautiful music. This duality reflects the tension between reality and imagination that runs throughout the poem.

Another important symbol in the poem is the cockatoo. The cockatoo represents the freedom of the imagination and the ability to mock convention and authority. This is evident in the following lines:

The green freedom of a cockatoo

That mocks the cult of the zoo

And beats his barred wings against

The brilliant, dim, and parrot-colored sky.

The cockatoo is a wild and untamed creature that defies the constraints of the zoo. It is a symbol of the human desire to break free from the constraints of society and the natural world.

Interpretation

So, what does all of this symbolism and language mean? What is the message that Stevens is trying to convey in The Plot Against The Giant? At its core, I believe that this poem is a critique of the human desire for power and control over the natural world. The girls who plot against the giant represent the hubris of humanity, our belief that we can conquer and control nature. The blue guitar represents the transformative power of the imagination, but also the dangers of creating false narratives that allow us to deny the reality of the world around us.

Ultimately, the plot against the giant fails, and the girls are left to confront the reality of the world they sought to conquer. This is evident in the final lines of the poem:

Did the dark hinderance, darkening, darken them?

Did they turn from the pastures of the sun,

To see the leisurely

Disintegration of the cloud, that seemed

To furnish them a memorial?

They wondered how the prince had fared,

What he had found.

Here, the girls are left to wonder about the reality of the world, and to question the narratives they have created. The disintegration of the cloud serves as a metaphor for the fleeting nature of human power and the inevitability of mortality.

Conclusion

In conclusion, The Plot Against The Giant by Wallace Stevens is a complex and multi-layered poem that explores the themes of power, control, reality, and imagination. Stevens's language is rich and evocative, and his use of symbolism creates a vivid and powerful narrative. The poem is a critique of the human desire for power and control over the natural world, and a reminder of the dangers of creating false narratives that allow us to deny the reality of the world around us. The Plot Against The Giant is a timeless classic that continues to resonate with readers today.

Editor 2 Analysis and Explanation

The Plot Against The Giant: A Masterpiece of Modern Poetry

Wallace Stevens, one of the most celebrated poets of the 20th century, is known for his complex and enigmatic works that explore the nature of reality, perception, and imagination. His poem "The Plot Against The Giant" is a prime example of his unique style and vision, which combines vivid imagery, philosophical insights, and playful language to create a rich and rewarding reading experience.

At first glance, "The Plot Against The Giant" may seem like a simple fable or allegory, with its cast of characters that include a giant, a king, and a group of rebels. However, as we delve deeper into the poem, we discover a wealth of meanings and interpretations that challenge our assumptions and expand our understanding of the human condition.

The poem begins with a description of the giant, who is portrayed as a powerful and majestic figure, "taller than trees" and "stronger than the seas." He is a symbol of nature, of the primal forces that shape our world and defy our attempts to control or conquer them. The giant is also a metaphor for the human psyche, with its vast and mysterious depths that we can only glimpse or imagine.

The king, on the other hand, represents the human desire for order, stability, and authority. He is the ruler of the land, the one who sets the rules and enforces them with his army. He is also a symbol of the ego, the conscious self that seeks to assert its dominance over the unconscious and the unknown.

The rebels, who plot against the giant and seek to overthrow the king, are the embodiment of the human spirit of rebellion, of the urge to challenge authority and break free from the constraints of tradition and conformity. They are also a symbol of the creative imagination, which can transform the mundane into the magical and the ordinary into the extraordinary.

As the poem unfolds, we witness the rebels' plan to trap the giant and defeat him with their weapons of wit and cunning. They use mirrors to confuse and disorient him, and they lure him into a trap with the promise of a feast. The king, meanwhile, is oblivious to the rebels' scheme, and he continues to rule with his iron fist, unaware of the forces that are gathering against him.

The climax of the poem comes when the giant is finally caught in the trap, and the rebels unleash their weapons upon him. However, instead of defeating him, they discover that the giant is not what he seems. He is not a mere brute or a monster, but a complex and multifaceted being, with a mind and a soul that are as vast and mysterious as his body.

The giant's response to the rebels' attack is one of the most memorable and powerful moments in the poem. He does not retaliate with violence or anger, but with a calm and wise voice that reveals his true nature and his profound wisdom. He tells the rebels that they have misunderstood him, that they have failed to see the beauty and the wonder of the world that he embodies.

The giant's words are a reminder that nature, like the human psyche, is not something to be conquered or tamed, but something to be respected and admired. They also suggest that the rebels' quest for freedom and creativity is not incompatible with the king's desire for order and stability, but that they can coexist and complement each other.

The poem ends with a sense of reconciliation and harmony, as the rebels and the king join forces to celebrate the giant's wisdom and to honor his memory. They realize that they are all part of the same world, and that their differences are not a source of conflict, but a source of richness and diversity.

In conclusion, "The Plot Against The Giant" is a masterpiece of modern poetry that combines imagination, philosophy, and language in a unique and powerful way. It challenges our assumptions about the nature of reality and the human condition, and it invites us to explore the depths of our own psyche and our relationship with the world around us. It is a poem that rewards multiple readings and interpretations, and that continues to inspire and delight readers of all ages and backgrounds.

Editor Recommended Sites

Recommended Similar Analysis